Analysis of the Effect of Combined Subsidies on the Indirect Tax Change in Khorasan Razavi

Document Type : پژوهشی

Authors

• taghi ebrahimi salari ¹
• Seyyd Mahdi Nemati Kheirabadi ²

¹ Ferdowsi University of Mashhad

² Ph.D. Candidate in Economics, Adalat University, Tehran, Iran

https://doi.org/10.22067/pm.v22i10.25534

Abstract

Targeted Subsidies is an important and visible part of the economic development plan which leads to a change in the subsidy. Factors such as the expansion and diversification of economic activities, the increasing role of government in the development of public services, social security, the development of government commitments in social and economic fields, efforts towards realizing economic growth, and equitable distribution of income have turned the payment and receipt of taxes to an important and effective tool. Taxation is one of the most important levers in the hands of the government which has a major role in preventing inflation and recession as well as in a fair distribution of wealth in the society.
Methodology
In order to reach the objectives of this study, the following question was raised:
Has the targeted subsidies plan affected the combination of taxes?
The statistical population included informed and clear-sighted people about factors affecting the tax income including experts of the tax organization. Statistical sample consisted of 35 persons and the method of sample selection was random sampling. After collecting questionnaires, data analysis was performed using SPSS software package. Given that the studied variable in this research is measured based on an interval scale, the following relations were used to determine the sample size:





Where, r is the upper bound of the relative error determined previously, N is the size of population, S and are population’s parameters (error coefficient is and confidence coefficient in level of 99% is equal to ). The required sample size for each group of statistical population was obtained as the table below.

Table1: population and sample sizes
Group Population size Parameter estimation from initial sample Final sample size
mean Standard deviation
Taxes on goods and services 82 3.65 0.72 35

The questionnaire queries the effectiveness of various factors on the amount of tax on goods and services.
Validity of questionnaire
Validity means to what extend the provided tool measures the considered specific concept (Secaran, 2001). The questionnaire used in this research has been validated according to theoretical foundations and the opinion of experts, intendants and advisers .
Reliability of the questionnaire
In order to calculate Cronbach alpha, firstly, it is required that the variance of scores of each subset of questions be calculated and then the total variance be determined. Then by replacing them into the following formula the value of the Cronbach alpha will be obtained:

Where, k is the number of subsets of questionnaire or questions of questionnaire; is the variance of kth question and is the total variance.
Thus, Cronbach alpha reflects the amount of positive correlation of the members of a set with each other.




Table2: Cronbach alpha coefficient
Row Questionnaire Cronbach alpha coefficient

1 Taxes on goods and services 0.840

Results and discussion
In checking his hypothesis, in order to get familiar with the manner of answers provided to the questionnaire and the significance test of each of them, firstly using frequency tables, we checked the answers. Then using t-student significance test, we checked the mean of answers so that a clear result was obtained about the view of respondents on each question.
Table3. reports the results of evaluating frequency percentage of provided answers to independent variable questions (Taxes on goods and services)
(%)
row Factor Increase so much increase Do not change decrease Decrease so much
1 Decreased export 0 20 48.6 28.6 2.9
2 Increased import 25.7 42.9 14.3 17.1 0
3 Decreased production (decreased economic growth) 2.9 77.1 0 17.1 2.9
4 Increased prices general level 2.9 77.1 0 1.71 2.9
5 budget deficit (increased government debit, more money issue for supplying government’s expenditure) 2.9 76.5 14.7 5.9 0
*See the rest of the table to text

As observed in the questionnaire, the scores given to each item of the questionnaire are as follow: highly reduces (1), reduces (2), does not change (3), increases (4), highly increases(5). Basically, the value of 3 is considered as the comparison criterion and test of mean comparison. The result of this test is reported in table (4) bellow.
Now, after t-student test and understanding the relationship between research variables, we draw path analysis diagrams to understand the direct and indirect effects of dependent and independent variables. Path analysis of variables studied in this research question can be seen in Graph 1 below.


Graph 1: Path analysis of research variables (Taxes on goods and services)

Conclusion
Totally, in the analysis of trends and the share of proceeds of direct and indirect taxes, it is important that before and after the implementation of the plan, no evident and significant change is observed in the trend of components and the total collected direct tax. In other words, the policy of targeted subsidies, at least in the short term, has had no significant effect on the amount of tax on goods and services proceeds.

Keywords

• target orientation
• subsidies
• taxes
• Input - output table

References

[1] Asadi Mehmandoost, E. (2009). "The necessity and how to modify consumption patterns and production of oil subsidies and its inflationary impact assessment", Journal of Energy Economics Studies, Year VI, No. 20(In Persian)

[2] Akbar, Allah's blessings, Mvdn Jamshidi, H. (2011). "The impact of subsidies on the income and expenditure of large cities, identify processes and the impacts of subsidies (the case of Metropolis)." Journal of urban planning and management, year IX, Issue 27(In Persian)

[3] Department of Commerce Bureau of Economic Research, (2008). "commodity subsidies" (In Persian)

[4] Fetini. Habib & Rabert Bacon. (1999). "Economics Aspect of increasing Energy prices to Broder prices in Iran" Document of World Bank.

[5] Frzbd, J., Mullah Mohammad, M. et al. (2010). "Operational strategies for administrative reform in tax systems Khorasan", Client: Province Administrative Staff development(In Persian)

[6] Frzbd, J., Mullah Mohammad, M. et al. (2010). "Strategies to increase tax revenue Khorasan", Client: Management and Planning Organization of Khorasan(In Persian)

[7] Frzbd, J., Mullah Mohammad, M. et al. (2002). "New sources of income Province", the province's economy and finance(In Persian)

[8] Grant Richardson. (2008). "The relationship between culture and tax evasion across countries: Additional evidence and extensions", Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation, 17, 67-78.

[9] Hope, Einer and Balbir, sing. (1995). "Energy price increases in developing countries", The world Bank policy Research Department public Economic Division.

[10] Heidari, Khalil et al. (2006). "commodity subsidies reform in Iran, with an emphasis on objectivity" Publisher: Tehran, Institute for Trade Studies and Research(In Persian)

[11] James Alm and Benno Torgler. (2006). "Cultural differences and tax moral in the US and Europe", Journal of Economic Psychology, 27, 224-246

[12] Majlis Research Center. (2009). "The impact of energy prices, industrial production and transport costs", Office of Energy, Mining and Industry, code 310, Serial No. 10112(In Persian)

[13] Reint Gropp and Kristin a Kostial (2000). "The Disappearing Tax Base: Is Foreign Direct Investment Eroding Corporate Income Taxes?" IMF, WP/00/173

[14] Sadeghi,Hossein, K. Shehab Mahmoud Lavasani and Baghjry. (2010). "The effects of energy price adjustment of macroeconomic variables using a regression model structural SVAR", Journal of Economic Modeling Research(In Persian)

[15] Skaran, Uma. (2001). "Research Methods in Management", Translated by Saba, M., Shirazi, Mohammad, Tehran, Public Administration Training Centre, First Edition(In Persian)

[16] Zvrar parmeh, M., et al. (2011). "Estimating the effects of energy subsidies reform plan, the level of prices of goods and services", Journal of Business Research, No. 58(In Persian)

[17] Yavari, AR, Nasir Aghdam, A. (2010). "Effects of targeted subsidies on municipal finance systems: a case study of Tehran", Proceedings of the Third Conference on municipal finance, Sharif University, Tehran Municipality, Tehran(In Persian)

[18] World bank (2003). "IRAN Medium Term Framework for Transition, Social and Economic Development Group East and North Africa Region", Report No.25848- IRN,April 30,page 66